I’m always seeing pictures of these pink frosted sugar cookies that you can get in America and I’ve always wanted to try them but we don’t have them in the UK. I feel like sugar cookies in general are under appreciated here, I don’t be seeing people eat sugar cookies. I don’t even know where I would buy a sugar cookie from but sugar cookies are great, I love them.
Anyway, I wanted to try recreating them. Do these taste the same as the ones you can buy……I have no idea I’ve never tried them but probably not. Either way, I still loved the way they turned out, I don’t normally like icing on cookies but these were so good!!

Frosted Sugar Cookies
Ingredients
Makes: 6 cookies
- for the cookies:
120g soft unsalted butter
90g granulated sugar
2 tsp vanilla extract
1 egg
240g plain flour
1/4 tsp salt
1/2 tsp baking powder
- for the icing:
150g soft unsalted butter
260g condensed milk
2 tsp vanilla extract
plus some pink food colouring and sprinkles
Directions
- cookies:
- start by beating the butter, sugar and vanilla together for 5 minutes
- now add the egg and mix this in
- in a separate bowl mix together the flour, salt and baking powder. add this into the other bowl and mix just until a dough forms
- wrap the dough with some cling film then leave this to chill in the fridge for 30 minutes
- at this point also pre-heat your oven to 180c/350f
- once the dough has chilled. dust your counter with some icing sugar or flour, add the dough on top of this and roll it out
- the softness of the cookie depends on how thin you roll out the dough, a thicker dough will give you a softer cookie. i like to roll mine out until it's 1cm thick, i feel like that gives a good softness
- cut out whatever sizes and shapes you want, i used a 8cm round cookie cutter for mine
- add these onto a baking paper lined tray, making sure to leave a gap between each one and then bake them for around 15-18 minutes. they're done when the edges of them just start to turn slightly brown
- icing:
- whip the butter for 5 minutes, you want it to lighten in colour
- add in the condensed milk and whip until you get a smooth icing. if it happens to split just keep whipping it and it will come together
- now just mix in the vanilla
- add the icing on to the completely cooled cookies, smooth it out a little, add some sprinkles and then you're done!
Video Tutorial
@ashbaber frosted sugar cookies 😏🤌
♬ Cafe - Ev Emanuel